Big Ideas Math: Modeling Real Life, Grade 8
BI
Big Ideas Math: Modeling Real Life, Grade 8 View details
1. Volumes of Cylinders
Continue to next subchapter

Exercise 10 Page 430

A cylinder is made up of two circles and a rectangle. Use this to compare the surface areas of the cans.

Can A, see solution.

Practice makes perfect

We want to find which out of two cans of soup uses less material. This is the same as comparing the surface areas of the cans.

A can is a cylinder made up of three pieces — the top, the bottom, and the side. Both the top and the bottom are circles and the side is a rectangle. The rectangle's width is equal to the height of the cylinder and its length is equal to the circumference of the circles.

The total surface area SA_\text{A} of a can is the combined area of the circles A_\text{C} and the rectangle A_\text{R}. \begin{gathered} SA=2A_\text{C}+A_\text{R} \end{gathered} To find the surface area of Can B we will first need to find its radius so that we can use it to find the area of the circles. Let's start by doing this and then calculate the materials needed for the construction of each can one at a time.

Radius of Can B

To find the radius of Can B, we will use the fact that both cans have the same volume. We know that the radius r_\text{A} of Can A is half of the diameter d_\text{A}. \begin{gathered} r_\text{A}=\dfrac{d_\text{A}}{2}=\dfrac{{\color{#0000FF}{3.5}}}{2}={\color{#0000FF}{1.75}} \text{ in.} \end{gathered} We now know that the radius of Can A is 1.75 inches, and that the height h_\text{A} of Can A is 3.6 inches. We can use this to find the volume of both cans using the formula for the volume of a cylinder.
V=\pi r_\text{A}^2 h_\text{A}
V=π ( 1.75)^2 ( 3.6)
Evaluate right-hand side
V=π(3.0625)(3.6)
V=34.636059...
V≈ 34.6in.^3
The volume of both cans is 34.6 cubic inches. Using this and the fact that the height h_\text{B} of Can B is 4.9 inches, we can find the the radius r_\text{B} of Can B.
V=\pi r_\text{B}^2 h_\text{B}
{\color{#FD9000}{34.6}}=\pi r_\text{B}^2 ({\color{#009600}{4.9}})
Solve for r_\text{B}
\dfrac{34.6}{4.9}=\pi r_\text{B}^2
\dfrac{34.6}{4.9\cdot\pi}=r_\text{B}^2
\sqrt{\dfrac{34.6}{4.9\cdot\pi}}=r_\text{B}
r_\text{B}=\sqrt{\dfrac{34.6}{4.9\cdot\pi}}
r_\text{B}=1.499219\ldots
r_\text{B}\approx {\color{#0000FF}{1.5}}
The radius of Can B is about 1.5 inches.

Material for Can A

Let's start by splitting up the surface area of the can into two circles and a rectangle.

The total surface area SA_\text{A} of the can is the combined area of the circles A_\text{CA} and the rectangle A_\text{RA}. \begin{gathered} SA_\text{A}=2A_\text{CA}+A_\text{RA} \end{gathered} We will start by calculating the area of each circle using the formula for the area of a circle and the radius r_\text{A} of the circles.
A_\text{CA}=\pi r_\text{A}^2
A_\text{CA}=\pi ({\color{#0000FF}{1.75}})^2
Evaluate right-hand side
A_\text{CA}=\pi (3.0625)
A_\text{CA}=9.621127\ldots
A_\text{CA}\approx {\color{#FF0000}{9.6}} \text{ in.}^2
Next, let's calculate the circumference C_\text{A} of the circles.
C_\text{A}=2\pi r_\text{A}
C_\text{A}=2\pi ({\color{#0000FF}{1.75}})
C_\text{A}=10.995574\ldots
C_\text{A}\approx {\color{#FD9000}{11}} \text{ in.}
Using the circumference, we can calculate the area of the rectangle A_\text{RA} using the formula for the area of a rectangle. Since the length of the rectangle is the circumference of the circles, and the width is the height h_\text{A} of the cylinder, we can rewrite the equation.
A_\text{RA}=\ell w
A_\text{RA}=C_\text{A} h_\text{A}
A_\text{RA}=({\color{#FD9000}{11}})({\color{#009600}{3.6}})
A_\text{RA}= {\color{#A800DD}{39.6}} \text{ in.}^2
Finally, the total amount of material needed is the area of the circles combined with the area of the rectangle. \begin{gathered} SA_\text{A}=2({\color{#FF0000}{9.6}})+{\color{#A800DD}{39.6}}=58.8 \text{ in.}^2 \end{gathered}

Material for Can B

The method for calculating the amount of material needed for Can B is the same as for Can A. We start by splitting it into the top, bottom, and side.

The total surface area SA_\text{B} of the can is once again the combined area of the circles A_\text{CB} and the rectangle A_\text{RB}. \begin{gathered} SA_\text{B}=2A_\text{CB}+A_\text{RB} \end{gathered} Just like we did when calculating the surface area for Can A, we start by calculating the area of each circle.
A_\text{CB}=\pi r_\text{B}^2
A_\text{CB}=\pi ({\color{#0000FF}{1.5}})^2
Evaluate right-hand side
A_\text{CB}=\pi (2.25)
A_\text{CB}=7.068583\ldots
A_\text{CB}\approx {\color{#FF0000}{7.1}} \text{ in.}^2
Next, let's calculate the circumference C_\text{B} of the circles.
C_\text{B}=2\pi r_\text{A}
C_\text{B}=2\pi ({\color{#0000FF}{1.5}})
C_\text{B}=9.424777\ldots
C_\text{B}\approx {\color{#FD9000}{9.4}} \text{ in.}
Now, we use the circumference to calculate the area of the rectangle A_\text{RB}.
A_\text{RB}=\ell w
A_\text{RB}=C_\text{B} h_\text{B}
A_\text{RB}=({\color{#FD9000}{9.4}})({\color{#009600}{4.9}})
A_\text{RB}=46.06
A_\text{RB}\approx {\color{#A800DD}{46}} \text{ in.}^2
Finally, the total amount of material needed is the area of the circles combined with the area of the rectangle. \begin{gathered} SA_\text{B}=2({\color{#FF0000}{7.1}})+{\color{#A800DD}{46}}=60.2 \text{ in.}^2 \end{gathered} Since this area is larger than the area for Can A, Can A requires less material to make. \begin{gathered} 58.8 \text{ in.}^2 < 60.2 \text{ in.}^2\quad \Rightarrow \quad SA_\text{A} < SA_\text{B} \end{gathered}