Sign In
The formula for the surface area of a hemisphere must include half the surface area of a sphere and the area of a circular base.
The formula for the surface area of a cylinder must include the surface area of the edges and the area of two bases.
Compare the formulas for the volumes of each tank.
Look at the variables involved in computing the volumes of the tanks.
2r/9
r/4
The ratio of volume to surface area is larger for the cylindrical tank.
The volume of the cylindrical tank is larger.
The radius of the tanks determines the volumes.
To compute an expression for the ratio of the volume of a hemispherical tank to its surface area, we will first need to find the formulas for each. Starting with volume, the volume of a hemisphere will simply be half the volume of a sphere.
\begin{gathered}
\textcolor{darkorange}{V_\text{hemisphere}}=0.5 \cdot {{\color{#0000FF}{V_\text{sphere}}}}=0.5{\color{#0000FF}{\left({\dfrac{4}{3}\pi r^3}\right)}}=\textcolor{darkorange}{\dfrac{2}{3}\pi r^3}
\end{gathered}
V_\text{hemisphere}={\color{#0000FF}{\textcolor{darkorange}{\dfrac{2}{3}\pi r^3}}}, SA_\text{hemisphere}={\color{#009600}{\textcolor{brown}{3\pi r^2}}}
Factor out π r^2
Cancel out common factors
Simplify quotient
.a/b /c.= a/b* c
Multiply
To compute an expression for the ratio of the volume of the cylindrical tank to its surface area, we will repeat the process using the formulas for a cylinder.
V_\text{cylinder}={\color{#0000FF}{\textcolor{limegreen}{\pi r^3}}}, SA_\text{cylinder}={\color{#009600}{\textcolor{teal}{4\pi r^2}}}
Factor out π r^2
Cancel out common factors
Simplify quotient
To compare the ratios of volume to surface area for the two tanks, we will substitute any value of r into both. For simplicity, we will use r= 1.
| Tank Shape | Ratio | Substitute r=1 | Calculate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hemispherical | 2r/9 | 2( 1)/9 | 0.22 |
| Cylindrical | r/4 | 1/4 | 0.25 |
We see that the ratio for the cylindrical tank yields a larger value. Therefore, the volume to surface area ratio is greater for the cylindrical tank.
Let's compare the volumes of the two tanks.
We can see that the only variable in the volume formulas is the radius r, making it the determinant for the volumes. Another way we can compare volumes is by comparing our ratios of volume to surface area.