Sign In
Did the students in those classes have some opinion on the death penalty before enrolling in them? How does that affect the conclusion which Stephanie drew?
See solution.
It seems reasonable to assume that taking a ceramics class does not cause being against the capital punishment. Let's design an experiment which would prove or disprove this statement. The study group for an experiment which answers this question would be a group of students. In order to check if taking ceramics causes opposition to death penalty, we should randomly split the study group into two test groups.
Afterwards we should compare the views in both groups.
Let's try to think what Stephanie did wrong. She only looked at two specific groups — the ceramics class and the government class. Chances are that those groups had some opinion on death penalty before entering those classes. It is plausible that students who take the ceramics are already opposed to the capital punishment rather than to think that the class influenced their opinion.